Free Shipping on Orders +$75. Consider Cold Packs & Express Ship for Warm Weather. Shop Now.

Small Batch Candy Collection

109 products

Looking for unique candies, that are handcrafted and delicious.  These artisanal candy makers are to satisfy every sweet tooth, while discovering something new.  

Filters

Filters
Filters
Sort: Featured
Sort

109 products

Close-up of Mayana Spring Passion mini bar cut to show salted caramel and passionfruit marshmallow layers, wrapper behind
Quick buy
Mayana Chocolate - Spring Passion Mini Bar
$5.50
Sold out
Front view of Chicago women-owned Candycopia collection showing assorted packaged candies in blue gift box
Top-down view of Chicago Women-Owned Candycopia Candy Collection showing a blue box with five colorful bonbons and a wrapped YUM caramel bar on a white background
Quick buy

1 review
Chicago Women-Owned Candycopia Candy Collection
$49.95
Front of Classic Pink Cotton Candy tub showcasing pink vanilla cotton candy in a clear plastic container on light blue wood
Label showing Classic Pink Vanilla cotton candy ingredients (sugar, vanillin, Red 40, artificial flavor, powdered sugar) and nutrition facts (2 servings, 100 calories per serving)
Quick buy

3 reviews
Classic Pink Cotton Candy
$6.85
Front view of Compartés Donuts and Coffee milk chocolate bar showcasing donut pieces and coffee grounds with white background
Quick buy

3 reviews
Compartes - Donuts & Coffee Milk Chocolate Bar
$13.95
Opening quotation mark icon
5-star rating icon
Candycopia delivered faster than expected and exceeded my expectations—definitely a new favorite treat shop!
Gentry
Front view of Jcoco Black Fig Pistachio 1oz chocolate bar showcasing purple packaging and 72 percent cacao label on a white background
Quick buy

2 reviews
Jcoco - Black Fig Pistachio (1oz)
$5.50
Opening quotation mark icon
5-star rating icon
Candycopia delivered faster than expected and exceeded my expectations—definitely a new favorite treat shop!
Gentry
Front view of jcoco Boharat Spice chocolate bar showing turquoise packaging and ‘61 percent cacao’ label; 61 percent Peruvian dark chocolate on white background
Quick buy
Jcoco- Boharat Spice
$5.50
Front view of Jcoco Cayenne Veracruz Orange 1oz bar in bright orange packaging showing 30% cacao on white background
Quick buy

2 reviews
Jcoco - Cayenne Veracruz Orange (1oz)
$5.50
Front of Jcoco Crisp Quinoa Sesame 1 oz bar showing yellow packaging with 47% cacao and quinoa and toasted sesame on white
Quick buy
Jcoco - Crisp Quinoa Sesame
$5.50
Sold out
Front view of Jcoco Edamame Sea Salt 1 oz chocolate bar showing green wrapper with 47% cacao and Edamame Sea Salt labels, copper foil edges on white background
Quick buy

1 review
Jcoco - Edemame Sea Salt (1oz)
$5.50
Front view of Jcoco Himalayan Salt and Toffee bar showcasing teal packaging and 47 percent cacao label on white background
Quick buy
Jcoco - Himalayan Salt and Toffee
$5.50
Front view of Jcoco Orange Blossom Espresso 1oz chocolate bar box showing orange packaging with 61 percent cacao label on white background
Quick buy

1 review
Jcoco - Orange Blossom Espresso (1oz)
$5.50
Fast delivery icon
Fast Delivery
Family owned icon
Family Owned
Dietary options icon
Dietary Options Available
Happiness guaranteed icon
Happiness Guaranteed
Front view of Jcoco Peruvian Dark with Cacao Nibs chocolate bar (72% cacao, 1 oz) on white background
Quick buy

1 review
Jcoco - Peruvian Dark with Cacao Nibs
$5.50
Angled view of Jcoco 5-Bar Gift Box (Milk) showing black-and-white box, Chocolate That Feeds text and five colorful wrappers
Quick buy
Jcoco 5-Bar Gift Box - Milk
$26.95
Packaged Mayana Chocolate Cloud Nine Mini with cut piece showing marshmallow, Fleur de Sel caramel and 66% dark chocolate
Quick buy

3 reviews
Mayana Chocolate - Cloud Nine Mini
$5.50
Three-quarter view of Mayana Coconutty Bar Mini with dark chocolate, exposed caramel and coconut beside black wrapper on white background
Quick buy

1 review
Mayana Chocolate - Coconutty Bar Mini
$5.50
Unwrapped Mayana Coffee Break Mini showing 66% dark chocolate with salted caramel center and coffee topping, wrapper beside
Quick buy
Mayana Chocolate - Coffee Break Mini
$5.50
Mayana Kitchen Sink Mini Bar cross-section showing caramel, peanut butter, pretzel and crispy rice with wrapper behind
Quick buy

1 review
Mayana Chocolate - Kitchen Sink Mini Bar
$5.50
Three-quarter view of Mayana Space Bar Mini showing bar cut open to reveal vanilla-bean nougat, toasted almonds, fleur de sel caramel and wrapper behind
Quick buy

1 review
Mayana Chocolate - Space Bar Mini
$5.50
Three-quarter view of Mayana Chocolate Spice Bar Mini, bitten to show melted salted caramel and tortilla-peanut crunch, red wrapper on white background
Quick buy
Mayana Chocolate - Spice Bar Mini
$5.50
Front view of Mouth Party 6 oz assorted caramels in clear cello bag with bright pink bow, individually wrapped
Quick buy

1 review
Mouth Party - 6 oz Assorted Caramel Gift Bag
$14.95
Showing 1–20 of 109 products
Shipping truck icon

Free Shipping Over $75

On all domestic orders. Ships in 1–3 business days.
Dietary-friendly icon

Dietary-Friendly Options

Vegan, gluten-free, & allergen-safe picks available sitewide.
Candy icon

Handpicked Sweets

Every treat is handpicked for quality, taste, and joy.

Shop by Categories

swedishsweetmix_963b4bbc-6337-4948-b3fe-e83731d2cfa6_1

CANDY MIXES

147 Products
malt_balls_TD_91b9ee02-6928-4173-b347-df80bc6914aa_1

Gummies

313 Products
348s_348x348_24628344-be23-4ed3-ac61-88623d7a27f4_1

CHOCOLATES

21 Products
Crispery_hero2_416x416_3e405595-cd46-44c4-9f83-36a7771407a9_1

Freshly Made

17 Products
Freeze Dried Candies

Specialty Candies

7 Products
image_6496

International Brands

312 Products

See Why 3.7K+ Candy Fans Are Obsessed

Unwrap joy, snap a pic, and tag @candycopia!

Smiling person holding two white Candycopia pick-and-mix bags in front of a Candycopia store sign

@foodisyourbudi

Woman smiling in Candycopia shop holding a white Candycopia bag in front of pick-and-mix candy bins

@olivia.radziszewski

Woman sampling a gummy candy in Candycopia with pick-and-mix bins and colorful candy displays in the background

@olivia.radziszewski

Customer smiling and holding a Candycopia treat bag inside a colorful Candycopia shop with candy displays in the background

@itsjessgameng

Smiling person holding two white Candycopia pick-and-mix bags in front of a Candycopia store sign

@foodisyourbudi